Calvin Klein Men's Puffer Coat vs Calvin Klein Mayden Slim-Fit Overcoat

Buy the puffer if warmth and casual everyday wear matter most; buy the Mayden overcoat if you need a dressier wool layer for work or evenings. The puffer is insulated, hooded and easy to layer, but it reads casual and the synthetic shell is less breathable. The Mayden is a slim wool-blend overcoat with a sharper drape and a distinctive green, though its slim cut limits heavy sweaters and it is a short jacket length. Owners of both styles tend to praise Calvin Klein tailoring; the puffer wins on cold-weather function, the overcoat on formality.

• Choose the Calvin Klein puffer if you want an insulated, hooded coat for cold casual days and easy layering.
• Choose the Calvin Klein Mayden overcoat if you want a tailored wool-blend coat for dressier wear and prefer green over black.