Which is better for everyday wear?

The JAXFSTK 5-pack, because five pairs cover a week of wear and it can go in the machine. The Candyman is the better single piece if you want a super low rise cut with a lifting pouch.

Which has better fabric?

They are nearly identical: 84% nylon and 16% elastane for the Candyman, 85% nylon and 15% spandex for the JAXFSTK. Expect similar stretch and feel.

Neither maker states a lifespan. The JAXFSTK pack spreads wear across five pairs, so each pair sees less use. The Candyman's thin waistband is the part to watch for stretch over time.

Is the Candyman worth buying over a 5-pack?

Yes if fit and cut matter more than quantity. Its contour pouch and thin waistband are described in detail, and it has a 4.5 rating from 178 ratings. The JAXFSTK has no rating given.

Will the JAXFSTK Medium fit me?

Medium fits a 28"–33" waist. Large covers 30"–36" and XL covers 33"–39". The Candyman is listed only in Small.

Can I machine wash either?

The JAXFSTK allows hand or machine wash. The Candyman's care instructions are not stated, so hand washing cold and line drying is the safe choice.

Candyman 9586 G-string Thong vs JAXFSTK 5-Pack Men's Spandex Thong Guy Men T-Back G-String Jockstrap Underwear Pouch Body Tanga Pants M

Buy the Candyman 9586 if you want one well-made thong in a specific color and size Small, with a contoured pouch and a thin waistband. Buy the JAXFSTK 5-pack if you want several thongs to rotate through laundry days and fit a 28"–33" waist in size Medium. The Candyman is a single piece; the JAXFSTK pack spreads the cost across five. Check current prices at each store before deciding, since no price was given for either.

Ask our shopping agent