Captiva Designs Modular Wicker Sectional vs Addison L-Shaped Modular Outdoor Sectional

Buy the Captiva if cushion comfort is your priority: its 9.8-inch cushions are the thickest in this pair, and the modular wicker pieces rearrange into a corner or a straight run. Buy the Addison if you want a frame that shrugs off weather with less upkeep: its charcoal aluminum frame with wood accents and zippered cushion covers is the more durable, easier-to-live-with build. Owners of the Addison call it firm and easy to assemble; the Captiva's wicker needs more cleaning and its back height is not published.

• Choose the Captiva Designs set if you want the plushest seating and a wicker look, and you don't mind wiping down rattan each season.
• Choose the Addison set if you want an aluminum frame that handles sun and rain with less care, plus removable, zippered cushion covers.