Which set is better for detailed work?

The Derwent Lightfast oil core is firmer and holds a point longer, which suits fine detail. The Luminance wax core is softer and better for broad, blendable coverage.

Are both really lightfast for 100 years?

Yes. Both meet ASTM D6901 and are rated lightfast for up to 100 years. Caran d'Ache rates 81 of its 100 colors as LFI; Derwent says all 100 colors are lightfast.

Which is better for blending?

The Luminance wax core blends more readily with finger or blender work. The Derwent oil core blends well too but stays firmer, so it smudges less.

Is the wooden box worth choosing Derwent for?

If you travel or store pencils long term, the wooden box is sturdier than Caran d'Ache's cardboard and foam. If the box stays on a shelf, it matters less than core feel.

Are the Derwent pencils vegan?

Yes, Derwent states all 100 Lightfast colors are vegan friendly. Caran d'Ache does not state a vegan claim for the Luminance set.

Which set lasts longer in use?

The firmer Derwent oil core wears down more slowly and needs less sharpening. The softer Luminance wax core is used up faster with heavy laydown.

Caran d'Ache Luminance 6901 Colour Pencils, Set of 100 vs Derwent Lightfast Colour Pencils, Wooden Box, Set of 100

Both sets are 100-color, 100-year lightfast, ASTM D6901 pencils, so the choice comes down to core feel and packaging. The Caran d'Ache Luminance uses a 3.8 mm wax core in a cardboard and foam box; the Derwent Lightfast uses an oil-based core in a wooden box. No current prices were provided for either set, so compare live store prices on this page before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent