Carhartt Bartlett Jacket vs Carhartt Yukon Extremes Insulated Active Jac

The Bartlett is the better everyday jacket: 12-ounce cotton duck, sherpa lining and Cordura-reinforced cuffs make it tough and comfortable for fall through mild winter. The Yukon Extremes Active Jac is the colder, wetter-weather pick, with 150g Thinsulate, a Level 4 warmth rating, Rain Defender DWR and a lighter 500-denier Cordura shell. Owners rate the Bartlett highly (4.7 from over 3,700 ratings) and praise its warmth and build; the Yukon costs more of your budget in bulk and stiffness but wins on insulation and weather protection.

• Choose the Carhartt Bartlett if you want a rugged cotton-duck work jacket for cold, windy days and prefer a relaxed, broken-in feel with a removable hood.
• Choose the Carhartt Yukon Extremes Insulated Active Jac if you work outdoors in deep cold, rain or sleet and need maximum warmth with a water-repellent, lighter shell.