Carhartt Montana Rugged Flex Insulated Jacket vs Carhartt Firm Duck Traditional Coat

The Traditional Coat is the warmer and more weatherproof of the two, with Arctic-weight insulation, a two-way zip behind a storm flap, and a longer 30.75-inch back. The Montana is the easier jacket to move and work in, thanks to stretch duck fabric, a relaxed fit, and a droptail hem. Owners rate the Traditional Coat well at 4.6 out of 5, and both share Carhartt's 12-ounce duck, quilted nylon lining, corduroy collar, and storm cuffs. Buy the Traditional Coat for deep cold and wind; buy the Montana for milder cold and active work.

• Choose the Montana Rugged Flex if you want a lighter, stretchy work jacket for cool-to-cold days and value freedom of movement over maximum warmth.
• Choose the Firm Duck Traditional Coat if you face real winter cold, wind, and long hours outdoors and want Carhartt's warmest insulation and a storm-flap front.