Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree vs Original 874 Work Pants
Buy the Dickies 874 if you want a cheap, wrinkle-resistant work pant with a classic high-rise fit; buy the Carhartt Rigby if you want stretch canvas that moves with you and a mid-rise cut. The 874 is $29.99 at Dickies as of November 3, 2026. The Rigby costs more and is the better pick for bending, kneeling and climbing.
Ask our shopping agent
Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree
Choose the Carhartt Rigby if you want stretch canvas, a mid-rise waist and a straight leg for active work.
- Stretch canvas flexes when you bend, kneel or climb
- Mid-rise sits comfortably below the waist
- Wide waist and length range, W28-W54 and L28-L36
- Six pockets and a straight leg that fits over boots
- No wrinkle or stain-release finish
- Cotton canvas is heavier and warmer than poly twill
- No published price in this comparison
What separates them
| Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree | Original 874 Work Pants | |
|---|---|---|
| Fabric | 8.5 oz cotton/spandex canvas with stretch | 8.5 oz 65/35 poly-cotton twill, no stretch |
| Rise | Mid-rise, sits just below the waist | High-rise waist |
| Leg shape | Straight leg opening | Straight leg that tapers slightly at the hem |
| Stretch | Rugged Flex stretch technology | None |
| Wrinkle and stain resistance | Not specified | Wrinkle Resistant and Stain Release finishes |
| Waist closure | Button and zipper | Hook-and-eye with zipper |
| Sizing range | W28-W54, L28-L36 | Standard waist and inseam sizes; shoppers report sizing runs off by an inch or more |
| Price |
Price history
- Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree: lowest $49.99 on Oct 29.
- Original 874 Work Pants: lowest $45.00 on Oct 29.
Prices at every store
Specs compared
| Spec | Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree | Original 874 Work Pants |
|---|---|---|
| Fit | Relaxed | Relaxed fit |
| Fabric | 8.5-ounce, 98% cotton / 2% spandex canvas | — |
| Rise | Mid-rise sits just below the waist | — |
| Leg opening | straight leg opening | — |
| Stretch technology | Rugged Flex stretch technology | — |
| Waist range | W28 - W54 | — |
| Length range | L28 - L36 | — |
| Model number | BN2291-M | — |
| Number of pockets | 6 | — |
| Closure | Button and zipper | — |
What reviewers say
Carhartt Rugged Flex Rigby Dungaree
Owners of the Rigby Dungaree generally rate it highly for comfort and durability, and many wear it as an everyday pant rather than only for work. Complaints tend to focus on sizing and on the pants loosening with wear.
- Comfortable stretch for bending and crouching
- Holds up to regular work wear and washing
- Useful pocket layout
- Looks good enough for casual wear
- Sizing runs inconsistently between pairs
- Fabric relaxes and can feel loose after a few wears
- Lighter canvas than traditional Carhartt duck
- Some find the relaxed leg too wide
Original 874 Work Pants
With over 277,000 ratings averaging 4.2 out of 5, the 874 is widely liked for value, durability and a clean professional look. The main complaint is sizing: the waist can be off by an inch or more and the same size fits differently across colors.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for bending and kneeling at work?
- The Carhartt Rigby. Its Rugged Flex stretch canvas gives where the Dickies 874's poly-cotton twill does not.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are 8.5 oz work fabrics. The 874's reinforced seams and poly blend resist wear and wrinkles; the Rigby's cotton canvas can fade and soften but the stretch helps it avoid stress tears.
- Is the Dickies 874 worth the extra over the Carhartt?
- The 874 is the cheaper pant at $29.99 at Dickies as of November 3, 2026, and no Rigby price is given here. The Rigby costs more for stretch and a mid-rise cut.
- Which fits better if I am between sizes?
- The Rigby offers W28-W54 and L28-L36, a wider stated range. Shoppers report the 874's waist can be an inch or more off and fits differently across colors, so try it on or size carefully.
- Which looks more professional?
- The 874. Its twill, tapered hem and wrinkle resistance give a cleaner office-to-site look; the Rigby reads as casual canvas workwear.
- Do either resist stains?
- Only the 874, which has a Stain Release finish. The Rigby's cotton canvas has no stated stain treatment.