Which is better for a parasite cleanse?

Both pair black walnut with wormwood, the classic cleanse combination. The Nature's Answer listing describes a 2 weeks on, 1 week off, 2 weeks on protocol, and its reviewers report cleanse results. The Carlyle gives a steady 200 mg of each herb daily in capsule form.

Which one is easier to take every day?

The Carlyle capsule. It is one quick-release capsule with a meal and has no taste. The Nature's Answer liquid is bitter, and reviewers often put the drops into empty capsules to avoid it.

Is the liquid worth about a dollar more?

Only if you want drops. At $10.28 versus $9.29 as of November 7, 2026, the gap is small, but the Carlyle bottle lasts about 120 days while the 1 fl oz liquid lasts weeks.

Which has a better rating?

They tie at 4.6 of 5. Nature's Answer has more ratings, 300 versus 169, so its score rests on more feedback.

Does either fit a gluten-free or kosher diet?

Both are gluten-free. Only Nature's Answer states it is kosher.

How long does each bottle last?

Carlyle: 120 servings at one capsule a day, about four months. Nature's Answer: a 1 fl oz bottle dosed by drops, so it runs out in weeks, not months.

Carlyle Black Walnut Wormwood vs Nature's Answer Black Walnut & Wormwood

Buy the Carlyle capsules if you want a fixed 200 mg of each herb per dose, a 120-day supply, and the lowest price: $9.29 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026. Buy the Nature's Answer liquid if you prefer alcohol-free drops and a formula built around a cleanse protocol; it costs $10.28 at eBay as of November 7, 2026. The two are within about a dollar, so the real choice is capsules versus drops, not price.

Today the Carlyle Black Walnut Wormwood costs $0.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.