Which fits a wider face?

The Cayman. It is built for average, large and XL fits. The Classic Timber is sized small to medium.

Which blocks more light?

The Cayman, at 11% VLT versus 13% for the Classic Timber. Both give 100% UV protection.

Is one worth more than the other?

No. Both are $58 as of November 5, 2026, so pick by fit and tint rather than price.

Which stays put better during activity?

The Cayman, thanks to no-slip nose pads and dual injected rubber temple tips. The Classic Timber relies on a standard bridge.

Which has the better track record?

The Classic Timber has far more ratings, 632,008 at 4.8. The Cayman scores slightly higher at 4.9 but from 64,532 ratings.

Do both include the same extras?

Yes. Both come with a microfiber cleansing pouch and a vinyl brand decal.

Shady Rays Cayman Polarized Sunglasses vs Shady Rays Classic Timber Polarized

Both are Shady Rays polarized sunglasses at $58, so the choice comes down to fit and lens tint, not price. The Cayman is the pick for larger faces and everyday wear, with a no-slip TR-90 frame and 11% VLT emerald mirrored lenses. The Classic Timber fits small to medium faces and has a wood-grain finish with 13% VLT grey lenses. Prices are level: $58 at Walmart for the Cayman as of November 5, 2026, and $58 at Shady Rays Eyewear for the Classic Timber as of the same date.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.