Challenger Oilskin Western Duster Coat vs Men's Wax Cotton Duster Coat
The Challenger is the heavier, simpler oilskin slicker: 100% cotton, button front, relaxed fit, and a long track record at 4.6 from 79 ratings. The Wax Cotton Duster is the more technical coat: snap closure with storm flap and throat latch, mesh back yoke, taffeta-lined sleeves, reinforced elbows, saddle gusset and leg straps, and a corduroy collar. Owners of the Duster call it sturdy, well designed and wearable in warmer weather, though its 4.7 comes from only 11 ratings. Buy the Challenger for a loose pull-on rain coat over work clothes; buy the Duster if you ride, work outdoors, or want venting and pocket detail.
- Choose the Challenger if you want a loose, lightweight pull-on oilskin to throw over clothes and stash behind a saddle.
- Choose the Wax Cotton Duster if you want a breathable, feature-rich riding coat with a storm flap, vented back and reinforced elbows.
Prices
- Challenger Oilskin Western Duster Coat: $119.99 at Amazon (checked today)
- Men's Wax Cotton Duster Coat: $68.00 at sharmabandhu.com (last seen Nov 12)
- Difference: the Men's Wax Cotton Duster Coat is $51.99 cheaper than the Challenger Oilskin Western Duster Coat at the latest prices (Nov 12 and Nov 19)

