Chanel Rouge Allure vs Guerlain Rouge G Lipstick

Buy the Chanel Rouge Allure if you want a lighter, hydrating satin lipstick that wears comfortably through a workday and comes in 20 shades. Buy the Guerlain Rouge G if you want a heavier skincare-based bullet, a choice of satin or velvet matte, and a refillable metal case with a double mirror. Chanel's build is the classic slim black tube; Guerlain's is the heavier, more jewelry-like case, and its refills only fit the new-generation case. Owners of both praise the pigment and finish, but Guerlain's velvet shades can feel drier on chapped lips and its shade range is narrower than Chanel's 20.

• Choose the Chanel Rouge Allure if you want a hydrating satin lipstick in a wide shade range that stays comfortable for a full day.
• Choose the Guerlain Rouge G if you want a skincare-rich bullet with a satin or matte finish and a refillable case with a double mirror.