Charms Party Pack Assorted Candy vs Chewy Candy Assortment 4 lb Bag

Buy the Charms Party Pack if you want a named, consistent mix: Blow Pops, Dubble Bubble, Cry Baby gummies, Sugar Babies and Mini Pops, all gluten free and peanut and tree nut free, in a resealable bag. Buy the Sugadelic chewy mix if you need volume and individually wrapped pieces for a piñata or treat table, and you accept that the selection varies bag to bag. Charms wins on known brands, allergen labeling and resealability; Sugadelic wins on piece count and wrapping. Owners of the Charms bag rate it well (4.6 from 463 ratings); the Sugadelic bag has no comparable track record, and its own listing warns the candy selection may vary.

• Choose the Charms Party Pack if you want a predictable mix of recognizable brands, peanut- and tree-nut-free labeling, and a bag you can reseal between events.
• Choose the Sugadelic chewy mix if you need roughly 400 individually wrapped pieces for a piñata or party favor table and don't need a fixed lineup.