Charms Assorted Candy Party Pack vs Canel's El Pinatero Pinata Candy Mix

Buy the Charms Party Pack if you want a bigger, better-known mix with peanut and tree nut free labeling and a strong 4.6 rating. Buy Canel's El Pinatero if you want a nostalgic Mexican fruit candy mix with gum, hard candy and lollipops for a pinata or goody bags. Charms wins on brand recognition, allergen labeling and owner ratings; Canel's wins on fruit-forward flavor variety and a lower-sugar profile per serving.

• Choose the Charms Party Pack if you need a large peanut and tree nut free mix of recognizable brands like Blow Pop and Dubble Bubble for a crowd.
• Choose the Canel's El Pinatero if you want a fruit-flavored Mexican candy mix of gum, hard candy and lollipops for a pinata or party favors.