Charter Club Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater vs Sonya Hopkins Sydney Cashmere Sunday Sweater

Buy the Charter Club if you want a classic, fitted turtleneck that holds up over years and comes in a wide size run. Buy the Sonya Hopkins Sydney if you want a loose, oversized organic cashmere sweater with a relaxed drape. Charter Club has the longer track record: 812 ratings at 4 out of 5, 2-ply yarn built to resist pilling, and owners who say it lasts. The Sydney is GOTS-certified organic and cut generously, but it has far less owner feedback and a boxier fit that won't suit everyone.

• Choose the Charter Club if you want a trim, hip-length turtleneck in 2-ply cashmere with a proven record and sizes from XS to XXL.
• Choose the Sonya Hopkins Sydney if you want an oversized, relaxed turtleneck in GOTS-certified organic cashmere.