Chesterfield Velvet 3-Seater Sofa vs Reveon Lakes Sofa

Buy the Chesterfield if you want a traditional statement piece with a hardwood frame, nailhead trim and a 900 lb weight rating. Buy the Reveon Lakes if you want a lower, deeper contemporary sofa with loose seat cushions and bolster pillows. The Chesterfield has far more owner feedback and a higher rating, but its listings disagree on dimensions and even on whether the upholstery is fabric or leather, so confirm the actual cover before ordering. The Lakes is a smaller, newer product with few ratings; owners call it good-looking and mid-firm, but some find the attached back cushions thin.

• Choose the Chesterfield if you want a classic tufted silhouette, a solid birch frame and a high weight capacity in a formal living room or office.
• Choose the Reveon Lakes if you want a deeper, taller-backed contemporary sofa with loose seat cushions you can flip and bolster pillows included.