Cinch Classic Solid White Button-Down Shirt vs Club Room Men's Regular Fit Dress Shirt

Buy the Cinch if you want a heavyweight 100% cotton white shirt with extra-long sleeves and tails that stays tucked and covers the wrist. Buy the Club Room if you want a lighter, wrinkle-resistant cotton-poly blend in a regular fit and a wide color choice. The Cinch rates higher with owners (5/5 from 19) than the Club Room (3.9/5 from 47), but it runs large, so size down. The Club Room is the easier everyday shirt; the Cinch is the better-made one.

• Choose the Cinch Classic if you want a pure cotton white dress shirt with extra-long sleeves and tails and a roomy classic cut.
• Choose the Club Room if you want a regular-fit cotton-poly shirt that resists wrinkles and comes in many colors.