City Chic Chloe Plush Knit Cardigan vs Calder Avenue Plaid Plush Cardigan Coat

The City Chic Chloe is the better pick if you want a stretchy knit cardigan that buttons over a top and reads as a normal sweater. The plaid plush coat is the better pick if you want a thick outer layer with pockets and a collar for cold days. The Chloe is a lighter, closer-fitting knit with a V-neck; the plaid coat is a loose, bulky plush piece with front patch pockets and a folded collar. Owners of plush coats like this tend to praise warmth and coziness but note the loose cut runs big and the plush pills with wear.

• Choose the City Chic Chloe if you want a soft stretch knit cardigan with a V-neck that layers over a blouse or tee and works indoors.
• Choose the plaid plush cardigan coat if you want a thick, pocketed outer layer with a collar for cold weather and prefer a loose fit.