Which is better for a plus-size shopper?

The City Chic Chloe, which is listed in US 16. The LILLUSORY tops out at XX-Large with an oversized cut, so check the size selector for your color.

Is the LILLUSORY worth the savings?

At $29.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026, it costs $40 less than the $70.00 City Chic at Belk. You give up a defined plus-size fit and machine washing.

Which is easier to care for?

The LILLUSORY is hand wash only. City Chic does not state care instructions for the Chloe, so check the label before buying.

The LILLUSORY runs past the seat by design. City Chic does not state a length for the Chloe.

Does either have pockets?

Both do. The Chloe lists pockets, and the LILLUSORY has two hip pockets.

Which has more color choices?

The LILLUSORY, with 19 colors, though not every color is stocked in every size. The Chloe is listed in pink only.

City Chic Chloe Plush Knit Cardigan vs LILLUSORY Oversized Knit Cardigan

Buy the City Chic Chloe if you wear a US 16 and want a plus-size cut with a button front and stretch. Buy the LILLUSORY if you want an oversized, past-the-seat cardigan in one of 19 colors at a low price. The LILLUSORY is far cheaper at $29.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026, versus $70.00 for the City Chic at Belk the same date.

Today the LILLUSORY Oversized Knit Cardigan costs $40.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.