Sid Mashburn Classic V-Neck Cashmere Sweater vs Gobi Cashmere Turtleneck Sweater

The Sid Mashburn V-neck is the better pick for most shoppers who want one versatile sweater. Its midweight 2-ply cashmere, saddle shoulder and fully fashioned build read as sturdier than the Gobi's airy light knit. The Gobi turtleneck wins on warmth and a sharper, structured shoulder, and its collar suits cold days and layering under tailoring. Owners of the Mashburn praise the heather finish and all-natural fiber; the Gobi has only a single review, so evidence is thin.

• Choose the Sid Mashburn V-neck if you want a lighter, dressier layer that shows your shirt collar and works across more of the year.
• Choose the Gobi turtleneck if you run cold, like a high collar, and want a structured shoulder for wearing under a jacket.