Which is better for a small reach-in closet?

The Wire Shelf Kit is enough for one shelf over a rod or above a washer. If you want two or three adjustable shelves plus hanging space, the ShelfTrack is the better fit.

Which holds more weight?

The Wire Shelf Kit is rated at 60 lb per shelf. ShelfTrack capacity depends on bracket depth and how far apart the standards are mounted, so follow ClosetMaid's spacing guidance for heavy loads.

Can I add shelves to the Wire Shelf Kit later?

Not on the same brackets. It mounts at a fixed height. If you expect to add shelves, start with ShelfTrack so the standards are already in place.

Which is easier to install?

The Wire Shelf Kit. It is one shelf with hardware and instructions included. ShelfTrack needs a hang track, vertical standards, brackets and shelves leveled across the wall.

Is the ShelfTrack worth stepping up to?

Yes if you are outfitting a whole closet or want to change shelf heights later. For one shelf in a pantry or laundry room, the wire kit does the job with less work.

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit vs ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Buy the ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit for a single quick shelf in a closet, laundry room or pantry. Buy the ShelfTrack system when you are fitting out a whole closet and want adjustable heights, multiple shelves and a hang rod. The wire kit is one fixed 36-inch shelf rated at 60 lb; the ShelfTrack is a modular track-and-bracket system with 12, 14 and 16 inch depths and pre-cut widths up to 93 inches. Owners of ClosetMaid wire shelving praise the vinyl coating and simple install; the ShelfTrack costs more effort and parts but gives a real closet layout.

Choose the ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit if you need one sturdy 36-inch shelf in a small space and want to mount it and be done.
Choose the ClosetMaid ShelfTrack if you are redoing a full closet and need adjustable shelf heights, several shelves and a hanging rod.

Prices

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit: $34.87 at DK Hardware (last seen Nov 10)
ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf: $32.92 at The Home Depot (checked today)
Difference: the ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf is $1.95 cheaper than the ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 11)

	ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit	ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf
Type	Single fixed wire shelf kit	Modular track, bracket and shelf system
Adjustability	Fixed height once mounted	Shelves move up and down on vertical standards
Shelf depth	12 in only	12, 14 and 16 in options
Widths	36 in	Pre-cut widths from 24 to 93 in
Hanging rod	None	1 in diameter hang rod included in the system
Load rating	60 lb per shelf	Varies by bracket and standard spacing
Install effort	Low: one shelf, hardware included	High: track, standards, brackets and shelves
Best use	Quick add-on shelf	Full closet build-out

Spec	ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit	ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf
color	White	—
size	36.3" x 11.8" x 1.5"	—
Shelf width	12 in.	—
Shelf length	36 in.	—
Finish	VINYL	—
Colour family	WHITE	—
Assembled product length	12"	—
Material	METAL	—
Assembled product width	36"	—
Package weight	2.87 lbs	—
Package length	1.10 in	—
Package width	11.80 in	—

Spec	ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit	ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf
Package height	36.10 in	—
Shelf material	vinyl coated steel	—
Capacity	432 Cubic Inches	—
Depth	12 in	—
Height	1 in	—
Width	36 in	—
Weight	3.9 LB	—
Product Type	Shelf Kit	—
Storage Type	Open storage	—
Style	Modern	—

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit vs ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Prices

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit vs ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Prices

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Specs compared

What reviewers say

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

Buying guides that pick them

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Specs compared

What reviewers say

ClosetMaid Wire Shelf Kit

ClosetMaid ShelfTrack Wire Closet Shelf

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

More comparisons

Buying guides that pick them