Coach Brooklyn 34 Shoulder Bag vs Coach Mini Carey Double Zip Crossbody

The Brooklyn 34 is the better pick for anyone who carries a tablet, a water bottle or a full day's essentials and wants a soft, slouchy shoulder bag. The Mini Carey is the better pick for travel, evenings and hands-free days, with a double zip, card slots and a detachable crossbody strap. The Brooklyn's rub-off grain leather is the more distinctive material and will age into a worn look; the Mini Carey's coated canvas and smooth leather hold up to scuffs and stains with less care. Owners of the Mini Carey rate it highly for its compact organization, while the Brooklyn wins on capacity and comfort for long carries.

• Choose the Coach Brooklyn 34 if you want one roomy shoulder bag that fits a tablet and daily essentials and you like leather that develops a worn patina.
• Choose the Coach Mini Carey if you want a small hands-free crossbody with secure double zips, card slots and a detachable strap for travel or nights out.