Which is better for carrying a laptop?

The City Tote. Its 6.25-inch depth and flat base hold a laptop or folders upright. The Brooklyn 34 is only 4 inches deep and slouches, so a laptop sits awkwardly.

Which one lasts longer?

The City Tote's coated canvas resists water, stains and scuffs with little care. The Brooklyn's leather is more durable in structure but shows scratches and needs conditioning to age well.

Is the Brooklyn 34 worth stepping up to over the City Tote?

If leather feel and a softer silhouette matter to you, yes. If you want an easy-care, structured carry-all, the City Tote does more for less upkeep.

Can either bag be worn crossbody?

No. The Brooklyn 34 has a single shoulder strap and the City Tote has two short top handles with a 10-inch drop. Neither comes with a crossbody strap.

Which holds more day-to-day?

The City Tote, mainly because of its extra depth. The Brooklyn 34 is wider but shallow, so it fits flat items and a pouch better than bulky ones.

Do either have a secure closure?

Both use a snap at the top and leave the main opening unzipped. The City Tote's inside zip pocket is the safer spot for keys and a wallet.

Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34 vs Coach City Tote

The Brooklyn 34 is the better pick for a soft, slouchy everyday shoulder bag in full-grain leather. The City Tote is the better pick if you want a structured tote that stands on its own and carries a laptop or folders flat. Owners praise the Brooklyn's leather feel and wide, comfortable strap; the City Tote's coated canvas is tougher and easier to wipe clean but feels less premium. Neither has a zip top, so both leave the main opening open to the weather.

Choose the Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34 if you want a soft leather hobo that sits close under the arm and carries daily essentials with room to spare.
Choose the City Tote if you need a structured, upright bag that holds a laptop and papers flat and shrugs off rain and spills.

Prices

Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34: $195.00 at Amazon (checked today)
Coach City Tote: $189.00 at Coach Outlet (checked today)
Difference: the Coach City Tote is $6.00 cheaper than the Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34 today

	Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34	Coach City Tote
Material	Natural grain leather with visible texture	Signature coated canvas with leather trim
Shape	Slouchy hobo that collapses against the body	Structured tote that stands upright
Carry style	Single wide shoulder strap, shoulder only	Two top handles with a 10-inch drop, hand or shoulder carry
Capacity and depth	13.5 x 12.75 x 4 inches, wide but shallow	13 x 13 x 6.25 inches, deeper body
Closure	Magnetic snap, open top	Snap closure, open top
Interior organization	One snap pocket	One zip pocket
Weather and wear	Leather scuffs and darkens with use; needs care	Coated canvas wipes clean and resists water
Laptop carry	Shallow body, no flat base; awkward for a laptop	Flat base and depth fit a laptop or folders

Spec	Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34	Coach City Tote
Height	12.75"	13.0"
Width	13.5"	6.25"
Closure	Magnetic Lock	Snap closure
Material	Natural grain leather	—
Outer Material	Natural grain leather	—
Closure Type	Magnetic snap closure	—
Carrying Options	Shoulder strap	—
Size	Mid-sized, One Size	—
Size Dimensions	4.0" (Width)	—
Size Capacity	Large Interior	—
Style Type	Hobo	—
Suitable Gender	Women	—

Spec	Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34	Coach City Tote
Gender	Women's	—
Use Case	Informal, Casual, Everyday carry	—
Age Group	Adult	—
Suitable Use Case	Everyday carry	—
Body Part Use	Shoulder	—
Suitable Age Group	Adult	—
Secondary Color	Brass	—
Compartment Highlights	Snap pocket	—
Depth	4.0"	—
Volume	Large Interior

Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34 vs Coach City Tote

Prices

Coach Brooklyn Shoulder Bag 34 vs Coach City Tote

Prices

Coach City Tote

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store