Which is better for carrying a tablet?

The Carey. It is listed as fitting an 8-inch tablet. The Nolita 19 is sized for a phone, cards and keys only.

Is the Carey worth $40 more than the Nolita 19?

Yes if you want leather, a zip closure, card slots and a crossbody strap. No if you only carry a phone and keys, since the Nolita 19 does that for $109.00 at ShopSimon as of November 4, 2026.

Which works better as an evening bag?

The Nolita 19. Its slim 7.5 x 4.5 x 2 inch shape and light canvas suit evenings out. The Carey is 8.5 x 6 x 3 inches and reads as a day bag.

Which has more carry options?

The Carey. It comes with a detachable 9-inch handle and a detachable 22-inch strap for shoulder or crossbody wear. The Nolita 19 is a shoulder bag.

Which holds its shape better?

The Carey's smooth leather body is stiffer than the Nolita 19's canvas, so it stands up better when partly empty. The Nolita 19 is the lighter of the two.

How many stores sell each one new?

3 stores price the Carey new and 6 stores price the Nolita 19 new as of November 4, 2026. More stores means more chances of a lower price on the Nolita 19.

Coach Carey Crossbody Bag in Signature Canvas vs Coach Women's Nolita 19 In Signature Canvas

Buy the Carey if you want one bag that carries a tablet, a wallet and a phone, and you want a detachable strap for crossbody wear. Buy the Nolita 19 if you want a small, light shoulder bag for phone, cards and keys. The Carey's best new price is $149.00 at ShopSimon as of November 4, 2026; the Nolita 19's is $109.00 at ShopSimon on the same date, so the Carey costs $40 more.

Today the Coach Women's Nolita 19 In Signature Canvas costs $40.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent