Columbia Bugaboot III vs Sorel Caribou Horizon GTX

The Bugaboot III is the tougher, more weatherproof boot: a seam-sealed Omni-Tech membrane, an injection-molded shell and 200g insulation make it a solid pick for shoveling, slush and icy sidewalks. The Caribou Horizon GTX uses a patented Gore-Tex liner and a Vibram XS TREK EVO outsole, which gives it better breathability and grip on mixed terrain, but its injected rubber shell and leather upper feel more casual than armored. Owners rate the Columbia well for warmth and value; the Sorel is the more refined, better-traction choice for everyday winter wear.

• Choose the Columbia Bugaboot III if you want a rugged, fully seam-sealed winter boot for deep snow, slush and icy walks.
• Choose the Sorel Caribou Horizon GTX if you want a Gore-Tex-lined boot with Vibram traction for everyday cold-weather wear.