Columbia Landroamer II Parka vs Barbour Bedale Waxed Jacket

Buy the Barbour Bedale if you want a jacket that looks right for decades and shrugs off wind and rain on the street or in the field. Buy the Columbia Landroamer II if you want a hooded, fully waterproof shell with synthetic insulation for wet, cold hikes. The Bedale wins on build, resale appeal and timeless looks; the Columbia wins on weatherproofing, hood coverage and packable warmth. Owners of both flag sizing: the Columbia runs large, and the Bedale's classic fit is roomy and can be tricky to size.

• Choose the Columbia Landroamer II if you need a hooded, waterproof, insulated jacket for cold wet hikes and city walks.
• Choose the Barbour Bedale if you want a waxed cotton jacket that looks sharp for years and handles wind and rain without a technical look.