Columbia Watertight II Jacket vs Feizor Men's Softshell Jacket

Buy the Columbia Watertight II if you need a jacket that actually keeps rain out on a hike or a commute in a downpour. Its fully seam-sealed Omni-Tech shell, adjustable storm hood and drawcord hem are built for sustained wet weather, and it packs into its own hand pocket. The Feizor is a softshell: windproof, breathable, with a warm microfleece back, but only shower resistant and sold without a hood. Owners rate the Feizor highly for fit and looks, though some report inconsistent sizing. Choose the Columbia for real rain; choose the Feizor for dry, cold, windy days.

• Choose the Columbia Watertight II if you want a packable, fully seam-sealed rain shell with a hood for hiking and wet weather.
• Choose the Feizor softshell if you want a windproof, breathable everyday jacket with a cosy microfleece lining for dry, chilly days.