Columbia Women's Boatside Leather Flip Flops vs Columbia PFG Boatside Flip Flops

The PFG Boatside is the better water shoe: drainage ports, non-marking rubber, an adjustable buckle and a heel tab for wet hands. The Women's Boatside Leather is the dressier pair, with a full-grain leather upper that holds up better for casual wear and looks less like gear. Both are light and grip well, but owners of leather flip flops report the strap and footbed wear faster when soaked, while the PFG's synthetic build is made to get wet.

• Choose the Women's Boatside Leather if you want a leather flip flop that looks smart on land and only sees splashes, not soaked decks.
• Choose the PFG Boatside if you fish, boat or walk wet docks and want drainage, a secure buckle and a non-marking sole.