Columbia Women's Navy West Virginia Mountaineers Fireside II Sherpa Full-Zip Jacket vs Columbia Men's Gold West Virginia Mountaineers Field Bound Omni-Tech Full-Zip Jacket

The Fireside II is a women's sherpa fleece for warmth and casual wear; the Field Bound is a men's waterproof shell with Omni-Tech, a hood and packability. They are different garments for different jobs, not two versions of one jacket. Buy the Fireside II for cold, dry days and lounging; buy the Field Bound for rain, wind and travel. Owners of Columbia fleece praise the softness and warmth but note it is not weatherproof; Omni-Tech shells are valued for keeping rain out, though the mesh lining and fabric feel less cozy.

• Choose the Fireside II if you want a soft, warm women's fleece for dry cold days and everyday wear.
• Choose the Field Bound if you need a men's waterproof, hooded shell for rain and wind.