Columbia Heavenly Hooded Jacket vs Columbia White Out II Omni-Heat Puffer

Buy the Heavenly Hooded Jacket for real winter: it has a longer 34-inch back, a fleece-lined hood and collar, Omni-Heat reflective lining, thumbhole cuffs and a drop tail. The White Out II is a lighter, simpler puffer with a plain zip front and no hood, so it suits mild days and layering. Owners of the Heavenly line consistently praise the warmth-to-weight ratio; the White Out II draws fewer comments and its care label is inconsistent, listing both hand wash and machine wash.

• Choose the Heavenly Hooded Jacket if you want one warm coat for cold, wet winters with a hood, longer coverage and thumbhole cuffs.
• Choose the White Out II if you want a lighter, packable puffer for cool days, travel or layering under a shell.