Columbia Hart Mountain II Half Zip vs Colosseum West Virginia Dolman Full Zip Jacket

Buy the Columbia Hart Mountain II if you want a warm, soft layer for cool-weather everyday wear and game days. Buy the Colosseum Dolman jacket if you want a light, stretchy hooded shell for mild days, rain, or layering over a tee. The Columbia is the warmer, more substantial piece; the Colosseum is the lighter, more weather-ready one. Owners of sueded cotton-blend fleece like the Columbia praise its softness and warmth but note it pills and shrinks if washed hot, while lightweight stretch-woven shells like the Colosseum draw praise for packability and criticism for thin fabric and little insulation.

• Choose the Columbia Hart Mountain II if you want medium warmth, a half-zip collar and a soft sueded fleece feel for cool days and campus wear.
• Choose the Colosseum Dolman jacket if you want a hooded full-zip shell that packs light, stretches with you and handles wind and light rain.