Will the Lnrkai pads fit a Command shower caddy?

Probably, but it isn't guaranteed. Lnrkai pads are generic and sized for common caddy brackets, while Command strips are cut for Command hardware. If the caddy is Command brand, buy the Command refill.

Which holds more weight?

Command publishes weight limits for its bath products and strips; Lnrkai gives no weight rating. For a loaded caddy, Command is the safer bet.

Is the Lnrkai pack worth it over Command?

At the same $5.47 you get 15 pieces instead of 6, so it's cheaper per piece. Command costs more per strip but fits its own hardware and has a longer review record.

Do both work on painted walls?

Command lists painted surfaces as compatible. Lnrkai lists only ceramic tile, glass and metal, so keep it off paint.

How long should I wait before loading them?

Lnrkai says wait 24 hours for maximum strength. Command also recommends letting strips set before hanging weight.

Which leaves less residue when removed?

Command states its strips come off without holes, marks or sticky residue. Lnrkai makes no removal claim, so expect more cleanup.

Command Bath Refill Strips vs Lnrkai 15 Pack Shower Caddy Adhesive Hooks, Shower Shelf Adhesive Sticker Replacement, No Drilling Bathroom Accessories

These are not the same product. Command Bath Refill Strips are genuine replacement strips for Command bath hooks and caddies, sold in a 6-count assorted medium/large pack. The Lnrkai 15-pack is a generic set of clear adhesive stickers and hooks meant for shower caddies and shelves. Both cost $5.47 as of November 6, 2026 — Command at The Home Depot, Lnrkai at Amazon. Buy Command if you already own Command bath products and want a guaranteed fit. Buy Lnrkai if you need many cheap adhesive pads for a caddy or shelf of any brand.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.