Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Tree Farm Flannel Sheet Set
Buy the Eddie Bauer Tree Farm Flannel set if you want warmth, a deeper 18-inch pocket, and a preshrunk flannel that softens with washing. Buy the Nautica Plot cotton percale set if you sleep hot and want a crisp, breathable weave that stays cool. The Nautica set is listed at $279.00 at American Blossom Linens as of November 8, 2026; no current price was given for the Eddie Bauer set, so compare its live price before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.
Choose the Nautica Plot cotton percale set if you sleep warm, prefer a crisp lightweight sheet, and need a 15-inch pocket fit.
- Crisp percale sleeps cool for hot sleepers
- Fully elasticized fitted sheet stays put
- OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified
- Machine washable
What separates them
| Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set | Eddie Bauer Tree Farm Flannel Sheet Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Fabric | 100% cotton percale, 200 thread count | Cotton flannel, 300 thread count, peached finish |
| Feel and warmth | Crisp, cool, breathable | Brushed, soft, warm |
| Max mattress depth | 15 inches | 18 inches |
| Shrinkage | Not preshrunk | Preshrunk |
| Wrinkle resistance | No | Not stated; flannel tends to wrinkle |
| Certification | OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 | OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100, not tested on animals |
| Set contents | Flat sheet, fitted sheet, pillowcases (count varies by size) | 4-piece set |
| Price |
Price history
- Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set: lowest $29.99 on Nov 7.
- Eddie Bauer Tree Farm Flannel Sheet Set: lowest $44.99 on Nov 7 at Gilt.com.
Prices at every store
Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set
- Home DepotNew
Availability unknown
$40.30Checked Nov 6 - JCPenneyNew
Availability unknown
$41.99Checked Nov 6 - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$44.99Checked Nov 6 - OverstockNew
Availability unknown
$46.54Checked Nov 6
Also available at
- American Blossom LinensCheck price at American Blossom Linens
- Tuesday MorningCheck price at Tuesday Morning
- isshoCheck price at issho
Specs compared
| Spec | Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set | Eddie Bauer Tree Farm Flannel Sheet Set |
|---|---|---|
| Pocket Type | Deep pocket | Deep Pocket |
| Max Mattress Depth | 15 inches | 18 Inches |
| Fabric Type | Cotton | Flannel |
| Thread Count | 200 | 300 |
| Fabric Weave | Percale | Woven |
| Age Group | ADULT | ADULT |
| Care Instructions | Machine Wash | Machine Wash |
| Sheet Highlights | Fully elasticized (fitted sheet) | Deep Pocket, Fully elastic fitted sheet, Preshr… |
| Set Count | 1 set | 4 |
| Set | Yes | Yes |
What reviewers say
Cotton Percale Bed Sheet Set
- 4.9 / 51,662 ratings
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from 1,662 ratings, buyers mostly praise the crisp, cool feel and the fit on deep mattresses. Complaints center on wrinkles and a slightly stiff first wash.
- CoolnessPraisedSleepers say the percale weave stays cool and breathable through the night.
- FitPraisedOwners report the fully elasticized deep pocket grips mattresses up to 15 inches without popping off.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for hot sleepers?
- The Nautica percale set. Its plain-weave cotton is crisp and breathable, while the Eddie Bauer flannel traps warmth.
- Which fits a deep mattress?
- The Eddie Bauer set, with an 18-inch max depth versus 15 inches for the Nautica set.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are cotton and machine washable. Percale tends to hold up well; peached flannel can pill with heavy washing, so wash it gently.
- Is the Nautica set worth $279.00?
- That is high for a 200-thread-count percale set. Check the price history and compare with other percale sets before buying.
- Does either come preshrunk?
- Only the Eddie Bauer set is preshrunk. Expect some shrinkage from the Nautica cotton set after the first wash.