Crosman 1077 Repeat Air Rifle vs Gamo Whisper Wildcat .177 Pellet Rifle

The Gamo Whisper Wildcat is the better pick for most shoppers: a gas piston break barrel with a quieter shot, a shockproof 4x32 scope in the box, and a 4.3 rating from owners. The Crosman 1077 is the choice for fast follow-up shots, since its CO2 semi-auto action and 12-shot rotary clip let you fire repeatedly without cocking. Build quality favors the Gamo's glass-filled nylon stock and self-contained power plant; the Crosman runs on CO2 cylinders that you must keep buying and that lose velocity in cold weather.

• Choose the Crosman 1077 if you want rapid semi-auto follow-up shots for plinking and don't mind buying CO2 cylinders.
• Choose the Gamo Whisper Wildcat if you want a quiet, self-powered break barrel with a scope included and no CO2 to buy.