Which makes better-tasting coffee?

The Grind & Brew grinds fresh beans right before brewing, which helps flavor. The Percolator boils coffee repeatedly, which can taste stronger but harsher. Most tasters prefer drip for everyday coffee.

Which is better for a crowd?

Both hold 12 cups. The Grind & Brew brews in about 2 minutes against about 5 for the Percolator, so it refills faster at a gathering.

Is the Percolator worth $90 when the Grind & Brew is $18.14?

The Percolator's rating is much higher, 4.9 against 4.1, and it is stainless steel. The $18.14 eBay price is far below the Grind & Brew's recent range of $51 to $99.99, so verify the listing before buying.

The Percolator's stainless steel body and carafe should outlast the Grind & Brew's plastic housing and blade grinder. The Grind & Brew has more parts that can fail.

Can I set either to brew before I wake up?

Only the Grind & Brew is programmable. The Percolator has no timer, so you start it by hand.

Which is easier to clean?

Neither carafe is dishwasher safe. The Percolator's wide stainless pot is simple to rinse. The Grind & Brew adds a grinder chamber and filter basket to clean.

Cuisinart Automatic Grind & Brew 12-Cup vs Cuisinart 12-Cup Classic Percolator

Buy the Grind & Brew if you want a programmable drip machine that grinds beans and brews 12 cups in about 2 minutes. Buy the Classic Percolator if you want stainless steel, adjustable brew time and temperature, and a 4.9-star record from 1,000 ratings. The Grind & Brew's best new price is $18.14 at eBay as of November 7, 2026, against $90.00 at Wayfair for the Percolator. That gap is wide enough to check the eBay listing carefully before you commit.

Today the Cuisinart Automatic Grind & Brew 12-Cup costs $71.86 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.