Cuisinart Frost Fusion vs Ninja SLUSHi

The Ninja SLUSHi is the better pick for most households: it needs no ice, holds more in the vessel, keeps drinks frozen for up to 12 hours, and has a self-serve handle that makes parties easy. The Cuisinart Frost Fusion is the stronger choice if you want soft serve as well as frozen drinks, a longer warranty, and a smaller footprint on the counter. Owners praise the Ninja's smooth texture and simple assembly but note it is slow without pre-chilled liquid; the Cuisinart's 5/5 rating is thin evidence next to Ninja's 2,300 ratings at 4.4.

• Choose the Cuisinart Frost Fusion if you want one machine that makes both soft serve and frozen drinks, value a 3-year warranty, and have limited counter depth.
• Choose the Ninja SLUSHi if frozen drinks are the main event, you want no-ice freezing, a self-serve pour handle, and drinks that stay frozen for hours.