Which makes better coffee for a small household?

The Cuisinart, because its 1–4 cup setting is built for small batches. The Black+Decker has no small-batch mode, so brewing 2 cups means using the full basket.

Which keeps coffee hot longer?

The Black+Decker. Its 4-layer vacuum thermal carafe holds coffee at 154°F or hotter for up to two hours. The Cuisinart relies on a warming plate, which can stew coffee and change the flavor.

Is the Cuisinart worth it over the Black+Decker?

If you need 14 cups or a small-batch setting, yes. If you mainly want coffee that stays hot without a hot plate, the Black+Decker does that better.

Which is easier to carry and clean?

The Black+Decker is lighter at 7.38 lb, but it is not dishwasher safe. The Cuisinart is heavier at 12.79 lb and uses a glass carafe.

Do both have programmable timers?

Yes. Both are programmable with a delay timer. The Cuisinart offers 24-hour programmability and 0–4 hour auto-off.

Which has the better track record with buyers?

The Cuisinart rates 4.6 from 1,800 ratings; the Black+Decker rates 4.4 from 2,252. The gap is small but favors the Cuisinart.

Cuisinart PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker vs Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Programmable Coffeemaker

Buy the Cuisinart PerfecTemp if you want a larger 14-cup batch, a glass carafe you can see through, and a small-batch setting for 1–4 cups. Buy the Black+Decker CM2046S if you want coffee to stay hot for up to two hours without a hot plate, thanks to its 4-layer vacuum thermal carafe. The Cuisinart holds 2 more cups and has a higher rating (4.6 from 1,800 vs 4.4 from 2,252), while the Black+Decker weighs less (7.38 lb vs 12.79 lb).

Ask our shopping agent