Denton Mens 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket vs Gap Men's Wool-Blend Car Coat

Buy the Denton 3-in-1 if you need one coat for rain, wind and cold, or want to split it into a shell and a quilted liner. Buy the wool-blend car coat if you want a dressier layer for dry commutes and office days. The Denton wins on weather protection and versatility, with a 10K waterproof and 10K breathable shell, taped seams and a water-repellent finish. The car coat wins on looks and drape, but a wool blend is not waterproof and gives limited warmth on its own. Owners rate the Denton higher at 4.8 from 645 ratings against 4.4 from 3,092 for the car coat.

• Choose the Denton Mens 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket if you face rain, wind and cold on a commute or walk, or want a shell and a warm liner you can wear together or apart.
• Choose the Men's Wool-Blend Car Coat if you want a smart, relaxed-fit layer for dry days, office wear and evenings out, and you already own a rain jacket.