Which is better for cutting metal pipe?

The Skil, mainly because linear mode plus its lighter 6.28 lb body is easier to control on pipe. The DeWalt will cut metal too, but it is heavier and has no orbital switch.

Which has longer runtime per charge?

The DeWalt. Its kit includes an 8 Ah battery against the Skil's 4.0 Ah, and DeWalt rates it at up to 102 cuts per charge in 2x12 pine.

Is the DeWalt worth the extra money?

If you cut every day, yes: more power, a bigger battery and lower vibration. For occasional home jobs the Skil at $116.10 at Walmart as of November 6, 2026 does the work for less.

Which is easier to use overhead?

The Skil. At 6.28 lb it is about 1.4 lb lighter than the 7.7 lb DeWalt, and it has a rafter hook and LED light for tight, dark spots.

Do both take standard reciprocating blades?

Yes, both use standard reciprocating saw blades. The DeWalt ships with a wood blade; the Skil does not include one.

Both use brushless motors, so motor life is similar. The DeWalt's larger 8 Ah pack and XR battery line generally hold up better under daily heavy use.

DeWalt 20V MAX XR Reciprocating Saw Kit vs Skil PWRCore 20 Brushless Reciprocating Saw Kit

Buy the DeWalt DCS384WW1 if you want the fastest, lowest-vibration 20V recip saw and a big 8 Ah battery in the box. Buy the Skil RS5884-1A if you want a lighter, cheaper saw with an LED light, a rafter hook and orbital mode. The Skil is the better value at $116.10 at Walmart as of November 6, 2026; the DeWalt kit costs more and no price was given here.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.