TOMS Diana Mule Sandal vs Firewalk Black Suede Mule

The TOMS Diana Mule is the better everyday shoe: a cushioned, removable CloudBound insole, a stable 2 3/4-inch rope-wrapped wedge and a vegan textile build, and its 4.5 rating from over 4,600 owners backs up the comfort claims. The Firewalk is a lower, flatter suede mule with a square toe, an adjustable buckle strap and Italian leather construction, so it reads more as a statement piece than a walking shoe. Buy the TOMS for all-day wear and long walks; buy the Firewalk if you want a distinctive suede slip-on with a buckle and a made-in-Italy build.

• Choose the TOMS Diana Mule if you want a cushioned wedge you can walk in all day, with a removable insole and a vegan upper.
• Choose the Firewalk mule if you want a flat suede slip-on with a square toe, an adjustable buckle strap and Italian leather construction.