Dickies Men's Leather Belt vs Columbia Men's Leather Belt

The Columbia is the better belt for most shoppers. It is real leather (split and bonded layers) and reversible, so one belt covers black and brown outfits. The Dickies is faux leather with a roller buckle and a narrower 35mm strap. It suits jeans and casual workwear, but the synthetic strap will crack and peel sooner than the Columbia's leather layers. Owners of both brands' belts report the Columbia holding its shape longer, while Dickies buyers like the easy cinch and the stamped logo.

• Choose the Dickies if you want a casual jean belt with a roller buckle that cinches fast and you don't mind a synthetic strap.
• Choose the Columbia if you want a wider leather belt that reverses between two colors and works for work, dress and golf.