Dooney & Bourke Pebble Grain Satchel vs Dooney & Bourke Pebble Grain Hobo

The Pebble Grain Satchel is the safer buy. It scores 4.7 from 62 ratings against 3.1 from 24 for the Hobo, and owners report far fewer problems. The satchel gives you a detachable 26-inch strap, a top handle, an outside zip pocket and protective feet. The hobo is lighter and simpler, with a 9-inch strap drop and a compact body, but reviewers repeatedly say the strap is nearly impossible to adjust. Buy the satchel for daily carrying and travel. Buy the hobo only if you want a small shoulder bag and will never touch the strap.

• Choose the Pebble Grain Satchel if you want a versatile bag you can carry by the handle or crossbody, with more pockets and a stronger owner record.
• Choose the Pebble Grain Hobo if you want a compact, soft leather shoulder bag for essentials and do not need to change the strap length.