Dooney & Bourke Penrose Hobo 25 vs Luna Paris Elegant Leather Bag

The Dooney & Bourke Penrose Hobo 25 is the better-made bag: full-grain Italian cowhide, a lined interior, an inside zip pocket, a key hook and a zip top, in a compact hobo shape that sits close under the arm. The Luna Paris is the roomier, more structured option: grained leather, a flat magnetic front pocket, a zipped back pocket and a body that fits an A4 folder and a phone. Reviewers of the Dooney praise the leather and the seller's packing and accuracy; Luna Paris buyers praise the structured look, the compliments it draws and the packaging. Neither is treated for water repellency, so treat both with care in rain.

• Choose the Dooney & Bourke Penrose Hobo 25 if you want a small, soft full-grain leather hobo with a secure zip top, a lined interior and a key hook, and you carry only the essentials.
• Choose the Luna Paris Elegant Leather Bag if you need to carry an A4 folder or a tablet, want quick-access exterior pockets, and prefer a structured shape that holds its form.