Which is better for someone cutting sugar?

The Cream Soda. It is the sugar-free version, while Creamy Coconut has 39 g of sugar and 150 calories per can.

Does the coconut flavor overpower the Dr Pepper taste?

Buyers say no. They describe the coconut as noticeable but not overpowering, with the Dr Pepper base still coming through.

Which pack lasts longer?

The Cream Soda, at 24 cans versus 12. Both have a 270-day shelf life.

Is Creamy Coconut caffeinated?

Yes, about 41 mg per can. The Cream Soda has only trace amounts.

Is the coconut version worth stepping up to?

Only if you want the novelty coconut flavor and regular sugar. Otherwise the Cream Soda gives you more cans and a sugar-free option.

Dr Pepper & Cream Soda vs Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda

Buy Dr Pepper & Cream Soda if you want a full-flavored cream soda with a sugar-free option and a bigger 24-can pack. Buy Creamy Coconut if you want a limited-edition coconut twist and don't mind a regular, full-sugar soda. Both are Dr Pepper variants with the same 12 fl oz cans and roughly nine-month shelf life. Owners of the Coconut version call the coconut noticeable but not overpowering, and the main complaint is that it sells out fast.

Choose the Dr Pepper & Cream Soda if you want a zero-sugar cream soda in a 24-pack and a flavor that stays in stock.
Choose the Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut if you want the limited-edition coconut flavor and prefer a regular, full-sugar soda.

Prices

Dr Pepper & Cream Soda: $31.50 at Walmart (checked today)
Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda: $6.97 at Walmart (last seen Oct 30)
Difference: the Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda is $24.53 cheaper than the Dr Pepper & Cream Soda at the latest prices (Oct 30 and Nov 9)

	Dr Pepper & Cream Soda	Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda
Flavor	Cream soda with the 23-flavor Dr Pepper base	Dr Pepper with creamy coconut
Sugar	Sugar-free (zero sugar)	Regular, 39 g total sugars per can
Pack size	24 cans	12 cans
Caffeine	Trace amounts	About 41 mg per can, naturally caffeinated
Calories	Zero-sugar formula	150 calories per can
Availability	Standard flavor, generally stocked	Limited-time release that sells out quickly
Shelf life	270 days	270 days

Spec	Dr Pepper & Cream Soda	Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda
Pack Count	24 Pack	12 Pack
Multi-Pack	Yes	Yes
Flavor	Cherry	PEPPER CREAMY COCONUT
Container Type	Can	Can
Size	12 fl oz	12 fl oz
Caffeine designation	Contains Trace Amounts of Caffeine	Naturally Caffeinated
Count	24	12
Product net content parent	288 Fluid Ounces	144 Fluid Ounces
Material	Aluminum	Aluminum
Shelf life	270 Days	270 Days
Texture	Liquid	Bubbly
Food condition	Shelf-Stable	Shelf-Stable

Spec	Dr Pepper & Cream Soda	Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda
Retail packaging	Multipack	Multipack
Product net content uom	Fluid Ounces	Fluid Ounces
Variety	Cream Soda	—
Sugar Content	Sugar Free	—
Net content statement	12 fl oz	—
Caffeine	—	approx. 41mg
Calories	—	150
Total Fat	—	0g
Sodium	—	55mg
Total Carbohydrates

Dr Pepper & Cream Soda vs Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda

Prices

Dr Pepper & Cream Soda vs Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda

Prices

Dr Pepper Creamy Coconut Soda

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store