Which tastes better, Made with Sugar or Original?

Most people find the cane-sugar version slightly lighter and cleaner, while Original tastes sweeter and heavier. Both share the same 4.7 rating, so taste comes down to whether you prefer cane sugar or the standard formula.

Is Made with Sugar worth the extra cost?

Only if you specifically want cane sugar and a glass bottle. Per ounce it usually costs more than Original, so buy it for the taste and packaging, not for value.

Which gives you more soda for the money?

Original. A 6-pack of 16.9 fl oz bottles is 101.4 fl oz, more than double the 48 fl oz in the 4-pack of 12 fl oz bottles, and it typically costs less per ounce.

Does the glass bottle keep it fresher?

Glass does not absorb flavors and holds carbonation well, which many people prefer. Plastic bottles are fine if you drink them within a few weeks.

Which is better for a party or a crowd?

Original, because the 6-pack of larger bottles pours more servings. Made with Sugar suits smaller gatherings or anyone avoiding high-fructose corn syrup.

Are these the same Dr Pepper flavor?

The base flavor is the same, but the sweetener differs. Made with Sugar uses cane sugar; Original uses high-fructose corn syrup and other sweeteners.

Dr Pepper Made with Sugar vs Dr Pepper Original

Buy Dr Pepper Made with Sugar if you want real cane sugar in a 12 fl oz glass bottle and care about a cleaner, more classic soda taste. Buy Dr Pepper Original if you want more volume per bottle and a lower cost per ounce in a 16.9 fl oz plastic bottle. Both are rated 4.7 out of 5, but Original has far more ratings (29,513 vs 402), so its score is more reliable. Compare live prices across stores on Deal.ai before you decide, since neither price was provided here.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.