Duchess | Walnut vs Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's
Buy the Duchess if you want a dressier, hand-finished leather Chelsea that slips on easily and looks good in an office or out to dinner. Buy the Forsake Lucie if you need a waterproof boot for wet city streets, light trails or winter slush and want to spend far less. The Forsake is $53.98 at Steep & Cheap as of November 3, 2026, while the Duchess has no price given here.
Ask our shopping agent
Duchess | Walnut
4.9Choose the Duchess if you want a polished, hand-finished walnut leather Chelsea with a stacked leather heel and a soft glove-leather lining for everyday wear.
- Hand-finished full-grain walnut leather that ages well
- Full glove leather lining and Poron insole for comfort
- Very high rating volume: 4.9 from 8,783 ratings
- Free US shipping and returns
- Not described as waterproof
- Higher dressy-heel profile is less suited to trails
- No price given in this comparison
What separates them
| Duchess | Walnut | Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's | |
|---|---|---|
| Water resistance | Not stated as waterproof; leather upper with rubber outsole | Waterproof leather and suede construction |
| Style | Dressy Chelsea with 1.25-inch stacked leather heel | Chelsea-sneaker hybrid with flat heel and round toe |
| Sole | Studded rubber outsole for traction | EVA midsole with supportive outsole |
| Insole and odor control | Poron antimicrobial shock-absorbing insole | Anti-odor lining treatment, shock absorption |
| Lining | Full glove leather lining | Not specified |
| Shaft height | 5.5 inches | Over-the-ankle |
| Ratings | 4.9 out of 5 from 8,783 ratings | 4.6 out of 5 from 211 ratings |
Price history
- Duchess | Walnut: lowest $160.00 on Oct 30 at Amazon.
- Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's: lowest $53.98 on Nov 2 at Steep & Cheap; $53.98 on Nov 3.
Prices at every store
Duchess | Walnut
- Thursday Boot CompanyCheck price at Thursday Boot Company
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's
- Steep & CheapNew
In stock
$53.98Observed Nov 3, 2026, 9:13 AM - Backcountry.comNew
In stock
$60.73Observed Nov 3, 2026, 9:13 AM - PoshmarkNew
Availability unknown
$87.00Observed Nov 3, 2026, 9:13 AM - eBayNew
Availability unknown
$89.99Observed Nov 3, 2026, 9:13 AM
Also available at
- Kittery Trading PostCheck price at Kittery Trading Post
- Out&Back OutdoorCheck price at Out&Back Outdoor
- ScheelsCheck price at Scheels
Specs compared
| Spec | Duchess | Walnut | Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's |
|---|---|---|
| Gender | — | Women's |
| Boot Style | — | Chelsea, Sneaker Boot |
| Type | — | Boots |
| Closure Style | — | Slip-on |
| Water Resistant | — | Waterproof |
| Material | — | Leather, Suede |
| Leather Material | — | Suede, Full-grain leather |
| Safety Features | — | Anti-odor treatment (lining) |
| Shaft Height | — | Over-the-ankle |
| Sole Material | — | EVA (midsole) |
What reviewers say
Duchess | Walnut
Owners rate the Duchess highly, with 4.9 out of 5 from 8,783 ratings. Most praise the leather quality, comfort and versatility, and many wear it daily. A few mention a break-in period and narrow fit.
- High-quality leather for the price
- Comfortable Poron insoles
- Easy to dress up or down
- Durable traction from the rubber outsole
- Stiff at first, needs break-in
- Runs narrow for wider feet
- Elastic goring can stretch over time
Forsake Lucie Chelsea Women's
Owners rate the Lucie Chelsea well, at 4.6 out of 5 from 211 ratings, and most praise its comfort and weather protection. Complaints tend to focus on fit and long-term durability.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for rain and snow?
- The Forsake Lucie. It is listed as waterproof, while the Duchess is not described as waterproof.
- Which is more comfortable for all-day standing?
- The Duchess has a Poron shock-absorbing insole and full glove leather lining, which suits long days on hard floors. The Forsake has an EVA midsole and anti-odor lining, better for active outdoor use.
- Is the Forsake worth the savings?
- At $53.98 at Steep & Cheap as of November 3, 2026, it is a low-cost waterproof boot. The Duchess is the dressier, more reviewed option, but no price is given here to compare directly.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Duchess has a studded rubber outsole and stacked leather heel, which tend to hold up well with resoling. The Forsake's EVA midsole is lighter but compresses over time.
- Can I wear either to the office?
- The Duchess is the better office pick with its leather heel and dressy profile. The Forsake reads as a sneaker boot and fits casual workplaces.
- Which has better reviews?
- The Duchess rates 4.9 from 8,783 ratings; the Forsake rates 4.6 from 211 ratings. The Duchess has far more feedback behind its score.