Duluth Forge Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert vs Kingsman IDV44 Direct Vent Gas Insert
The Duluth Forge is the simpler buy for a room that needs supplemental heat without a chimney: it runs on liquid propane, vents nothing outside, and heats up to 1,350 sq. ft. with a thermostat remote. The Kingsman IDV44 is a heavier, built-in direct-vent insert for converting an existing wood fireplace, with a sealed ceramic-glass firebox, a heat-activated variable-speed blower and a 34,250 BTU input. Owners of vent-free units like the Duluth praise the heat output and note the moisture and odor that come with ventless operation; Kingsman owners value the sealed firebox and blower but accept the venting work and higher install effort.
- Choose the Duluth Forge if you want a vent-free propane insert that drops into a wall or mantel and heats a large room without a chimney or outside vent.
- Choose the Kingsman IDV44 if you are converting an existing wood fireplace and can run a 3-inch/4-inch direct vent, and you want a sealed glass front with a blower.
Prices
- Duluth Forge Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert: $609.34 at The Home Depot (checked today)
- Kingsman IDV44 Direct Vent Gas Insert: $3,228.50 at US Fireplace Store (checked today)
- Difference: the Duluth Forge Ventless Gas Fireplace Insert is $2,619.16 cheaper than the Kingsman IDV44 Direct Vent Gas Insert today

