Which is better for pet hair?

Both handle pet hair well. The V16's dual conical brushes strip long hair into the bin, while the Gen5 Detect's Motorbar uses de-tangling vanes. The V16 has more suction, but the Gen5 Detect is easier to push around a hairy home.

Which is easier to use on stairs and above floors?

The Gen5 Detect. Owners of the V16 complain about weight and manoeuvrability, and both convert to handhelds, but the Gen5 Detect is the friendlier of the two in tight spaces.

Does the V16 really hold 30 days of dust?

That figure comes from Dyson's own test conditions. The CleanCompaktor bin compresses debris, so in normal use you empty it less often than the Gen5 Detect's 0.2 gal bin, but not necessarily once a month.

Is the Gen5 Detect worth stepping up to over the V16?

If handling matters, yes. You give up some suction and bin capacity, but you get a better-regarded vacuum with whole-machine HEPA and a proven cleaner head.

Which charges faster?

The V16, at about 3.5 hours versus 4.5 hours for the Gen5 Detect.

Do both filter fine dust?

Yes. Both use sealed HEPA filtration. The V16 is rated to capture 99.99% of particles down to 0.1 microns; the Gen5 Detect uses whole-machine HEPA filtration.

Dyson V16 Piston Animal vs Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Both are premium cordless sticks with sealed HEPA filtration and around 70 minutes of eco runtime. The V16 Piston Animal pushes more suction (315 AW vs 300 W max) and compresses dust so the bin goes longer between empties, but owners repeatedly call it heavy and awkward, and its rating sits at 3.8. The Gen5 Detect is the safer pick for most homes: lighter feel in the hand, a proven de-tangle Motorbar head, and a cleaner track record with reviewers. Buy the V16 if raw suction and fewer bin empties matter most; buy the Gen5 Detect if you want easier handling day to day.

Choose the Dyson V16 Piston Animal if you have thick carpets and pet hair and want the strongest suction Dyson sells in a stick, and you can live with the weight.
Choose the Dyson Gen5 Detect if you want a proven all-round cordless that is easier to manoeuvre and has a better owner reputation.

Prices

Dyson V16 Piston Animal: $299.00 at Deorta Appliance (last seen Nov 6)
Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum: $490.00 at ModeSens (last seen Nov 8)
Difference: the Dyson V16 Piston Animal is $191.00 cheaper than the Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum at the latest prices (Nov 6 and Nov 8)

	Dyson V16 Piston Animal	Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum
Suction	315 AW in Boost mode	300 W max mode
Weight	7.5 lb	7.72 lb
Bin capacity	0.35 gal, compacts dust to hold up to 30 days of debris	0.2 gal, no compaction
Charge time	3.5 hrs	4.5 hrs
Filtration	Sealed five-stage HEPA, 99.99% to 0.1 microns	Whole-machine HEPA
Cleaner head	All Floor Cones Sense with dual conical anti-tangle brushes	Digital Motorbar with de-tangling vanes
Handling	Owners report heavy, hard to manoeuvre, suction drops on the back stroke	Lighter feel and better regarded for everyday use
Owner rating	3.8 out of 5 from 236 ratings	No comparable rating data

Spec	Dyson V16 Piston Animal	Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum
Maximum run time	70 min	70 min
Charge time	3.5 hrs	4.5 hrs
Bin volume	0.35 gallon	0.2 gallon
Weight	7.5 lb	7.72 lb
Height	10.2 in	50.2 in
Length	51.1 in	10.87 in
Width	9.84 in	9.8 in
Filtration	99.99% to 0.1 microns	Whole-machine HEPA filtration
Type	Stick	Stick
Bagless	Yes	Yes
HEPA Filter	Yes	Yes
Color	Black	Purple

Spec	Dyson V16 Piston Animal	Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum
Capacity	0.34 gal	20.34 gal
Convertible	Yes	Yes
Suction power	315 AW	—
Motor power	900w	—
Battery cells	seven-cell	—
Dust capacity	30 days’ of dust	—
For Pets	Yes	—
Surface Type	All floor types, Carpets, Hard floors	—
Wet / Dry	Yes (wet cleaning for spills and stains on hard…	—
Water Tank Capacity

Dyson V16 Piston Animal vs Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Prices

Dyson V16 Piston Animal vs Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Prices

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

Buying guides that pick them

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Specs compared

What reviewers say

Dyson V16 Piston Animal

Dyson Gen5 Detect Cordless Vacuum

Questions and answers

Ask our shopping agent

More comparisons

Buying guides that pick them