Eastland Men's Yarmouth vs Eastland Baja Chelsea Boot

The Yarmouth is the better everyday shoe: full-grain leather, a leather lining, a cork-and-memory-foam footbed and a grippy rubber sole in a classic boat-shoe shape. The Baja is a women's Chelsea boot with a synthetic upper, a 5-inch shaft and a 1.5-inch block heel, so it suits wet-weather commuting and a dressier look rather than long walks. Owners of Eastland boat shoes tend to praise the break-in comfort and complain about the leather stretching; the Baja's synthetic upper needs less care but breathes less and wears faster. Buy the Yarmouth for casual wear and the Baja if you want a pull-on boot.

• Choose the Eastland Yarmouth if you want a breathable leather boat shoe for warm days, wide feet or long walks.
• Choose the Eastland Baja Boot if you want a slip-on women's Chelsea boot with a heel and a taller shaft for cooler, wetter days.