ECCO Golf S-Casual vs Cole Haan GrandPro All-Day Golf

Buy the ECCO S-Casual if you play real rounds in wet or uneven conditions and want a spikeless shoe that grips and keeps water out. Buy the Cole Haan GrandPro All-Day if golf is a walk with friends and you want a light, sneaker-like shoe you can wear off the course. The ECCO is the more purpose-built golf shoe: full leather, a waterproof membrane, a washable OrthoLite insole and roughly 100 TPU traction bars with 800 traction angles. The Cole Haan is softer and more casual, with an ENERGYFEEL midsole and a removable PU footbed, but its waterproofing is leather plus sealed seams rather than a membrane, and its rubber outsole is less aggressive. Owners of both praise comfort out of the box; the ECCO holds up better over seasons of play.

• Choose the ECCO Golf S-Casual if you want a waterproof leather golf shoe with real traction for wet mornings and full rounds.
• Choose the Cole Haan GrandPro All-Day if you want a light, sneaker-style shoe that works on the course and around town.