Which is better for a queen bed?

The Eddie Bauer Alani Island. Its Full/Queen size is 90 by 90 inches and it includes shams. The Donna Sharp Rustica is a 50 by 60 inch throw and will not cover a queen mattress.

Which feels cooler at night?

The Eddie Bauer, because its face is cotton and it is listed as breathable. The Donna Sharp Rustica is polyester, which traps heat more.

Is the Donna Sharp Rustica worth it as a throw?

Yes if you want a lightweight patchwork throw for a sofa or chair. It is machine washable in cold water and tumble dry, and it is rated 5 of 5, though from just 12 ratings.

The Eddie Bauer has the edge on paper: cotton face, reversible stitching and a larger rating base of 63. Polyester like the Rustica resists shrinking but can pill with heavy washing.

How do the prices compare?

The Eddie Bauer Alani Island ranged from $31.42 on November 4, 2026 to $59.07 on November 1, 2026. No price was given for the Donna Sharp Rustica, so check its current store price before deciding.

Can I use the Eddie Bauer quilt outdoors?

Yes. Eddie Bauer lists outdoor use as a top use case, and the 90 by 90 inch size works as a ground or picnic blanket.

Eddie Bauer Alani Island Quilt Set vs Donna Sharp Rustica Quilt

Buy the Eddie Bauer Alani Island if you need a full bed quilt set: it comes in Twin, Full/Queen and King at 90 by 90 inches, is reversible cotton, and its lowest recent price was $31.42 on November 4, 2026, against a high of $59.07 on November 1, 2026. Choose the Donna Sharp Rustica only if you want a small 50 by 60 inch polyester throw with a patchwork look. The Rustica is a throw, not a bed-sized quilt, so the two are not direct substitutes.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.